Odjek roditeljskih vjerskih i filozofskih uvjerenja na odgoj i obrazovanje djece u hrvatskoj legislativi
Dr. sc. Dubravka Hrabar, profesorica Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Zagrebu, Trg Republike Hrvatske 14, Zagreb; dubravka.hrabar@pravo.hr; ORCID ID: orcid.org/0000-0002-4103-8190
Sažetak
Obiteljski zakonodavac već niz godina prava djece uređuje na način komplementaran roditeljskim pravima, dužnostima i odgovornostima. Pravo kao vjerni pratitelj društvenih promjena treba odgovoriti na novopostavljene društvene ciljeve. Nacrt novoga Prijedloga Obiteljskog zakona propisao je pravo roditelja da utječu na obrazovanje djece kroz pouku koja odgovara njihovim vjerskim i filozofskim uvjerenjima. Dakako, to pravo relativnoga karaktera, omeđeno nekolicinom djetetovih prava i njegovom dobrobiti, imalo je cilj u okvirima obiteljskih odnosa ojačati roditeljsku odgojnu funkciju. Prijedlog Obiteljskog zakona kretao se upravo na tragu više međunarodnih ugovora koji izrijekom to pravo priznaju roditeljima, no napadi na ovu odredbu kriju želju i potrebu njegovih osporavatelja da se o obiteljskopravnoj materiji govori s ideoloških pozicija. U radu se kratko polemizira, uz pravnu argumentaciju, s takvim pristupom i zalaže se za vladavinu prava, koja (i) u ovome slučaju podrazumijeva jasne i nedvojbene norme, utemeljene na međunarodnim propisima.
Ključne riječi
odgoj; obrazovanje; vjerska i filozofska uvjerenja
Hrčak ID: 207486
URI
https://hrcak.srce.hr/207486
Stranice
319-336
__________________________________________________________________________________________
The Reflection of Parental Religious and Philosophical Convictions on Child’s Upbringing and Education in Croatian Legislation
Dubravka Hrabar, Ph. D., Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Zagreb, Trg Republike Hrvatske 14, Zagreb; dubravka.hrabar@pravo.hr; ORCID ID: orcid.org/0000-0002-4103-8190
Summary
For many years the family legislator has regulated the rights of the child in a complementary manner to parental rights, duties and responsibilities. “Right” as a faithful companion to social changes should respond to newly established social goals. Children’s upbringing provided by their parents is a separate and different subject to children’s education, but these two issues are very closely linked. Several international and European legal instruments, which are the subject of this paper, guarantee the child’s right to education and his/her right to be brought up by his or her parents. The parental influence on a child’s upbringing and his/her education is indisputable according to all international instruments. The European Court of Human Rights has dealt with various issues mostly concerning the parents’ religious or philosophical convictions, and has brought more clarity to the discussion, such as the meaning of the terms ‘respect of the right of parents” or “respect” etc. pointing out the state’s positive duties. The draft of the new Family Law Act prescribes the right of parents to influence the education of their children through teaching that suits their religious and philosophical beliefs. Of course, this right is of a relative character, bound by particular children’s rights and welfare; it was indeed intended to strengthen the parental educational function within the framework of family relationships. The draft of the Family Act precisely follows several international treaties, which explicitly acknowledge this right of parents. Unfortunately, the attacks by its opponents focused on this provision having in mind an ideological approach to family law issues. This paper briefly criticizes, with legal arguments, such an approach and is committed to the rule of law, which (also) in this case implies clear and unambiguous norms based on international documents.
Key words
upbringing; education; religious and philosophical convictions
Hrčak ID: 207486
URI
https://hrcak.srce.hr/207486
Pages
319-336